After becoming involved in the equestrian community, most horse enthusiasts start to hear about the Western versus English debate. Which is better for the horse? Which is more comfortable? And, in the more heated arguments, which should be stripped from the earth and banned for the rest of eternity?
The real truth is that English riding is not much different from Western riding. Both seek to establish a connection between horse and rider, and there are ways to abuse or injure a horse in either discipline.
English Saddle Versus Western Saddle
The primary surface difference between English riding and Western riding is the equipment. The Western saddle is designed to facilitate comfort on long cattle drives, and is built for roping calves and cutting steer and a host of other activities. An English saddle, on the other hand, is flatter and designed for less contact.
Of course, there are numerous types of Western saddles, just as many forms of the English saddle exist. The main differences between the two categories are:
- The Western saddle has a horn on the pommel
- English saddles have a girth rather than a cinch
- Stirrups are attached to the English saddle with slim leathers, while the Western saddle uses fenders
- The cantle is higher on the Western saddle
- The Western seat is deeper and more sloped
There are also differences when comparing other equipment used for Western or English riding. The English bridle, for example, has a cavesson (noseband) and browband, while the Western bridle has only a headstall (sometimes with an earslot). Also, the Western saddle pad is larger and thicker than the English one.
Direct Rein Versus Neck Rein
In English riding, horses are taught to respond to direct reining, which means that the rider holds the left rein in his left hand, and the right rein in his right hand. There is a straight line from the hand to the bit via the rein, which means that every cue is directed at the horse's mouth.
Western riding uses neck reining, however, which is much different. In neck reining, the rider holds both reins in the same hand, and lays the reins across the neck to indicate a turn in one direction or another. Younger horses are sometimes taught direct reining first, and then evolve to neck reining after gaining more experience.
Saddle Position
The focus in Western riding is comfort, though precision is equally important in Western events. The rider sits deeper in the saddle, with longer stirrups and a more relaxed posture. In English riding, the stirrups are shorter to facilitate lifting out of the saddle, and the posture is more erect.
In Western equestrian disciplines, riders sometimes hold their hands farther apart when using direct rein, or hold their hands higher for neck reining.
Similarities
Despite all these differences (and more), there are numerous similarities between Western and English riding. For one thing, the goal in both equestrian disciplines is to establish a working relationship between horse and rider.
Horseback riders always use contact with their three seat bones in order to communicate more effectively with their horses. They should sit with their eyes up and their shoulders back, and with their weight in their heels. Riders of all equestrian disciplines should ride with a helmet.
The Western versus English debate is unlikely to end in the near future, but riders of all equestrian disciplines might learn more from each other if they work together. English riders should try out Western riding for a change of pace every once in a while, and vice versa.
 |
